Crawford - 2/18/2007 - another, albeit on the mild side, mishap

vftt.org

Help Support vftt.org:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

sapblatt

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 22, 2004
Messages
2,177
Reaction score
286
Location
Massachusetts Avatar: "Heads or tails?!"
LarryD and I wanted to get out and we also wanted to avoid a killer trail break session. We read on Saturday that the Davis Path had been broken out on Saturday so we opted to attempt Crawford and maybe a bit more via the Davis Path.

We hit the trail at 7:25 under partly cloudy skies and occasional flurries. We were amazed at how mild it was outside - 25 degrees and no wind at all. We both wore MSR snowshoes with extension tails. These were a good choice for the first part of the day - more on that later.

We crossed the Bemis Bridge and went my the two houses and were quickly on our way through about two feet of sno most of the day. The people who broke the trail did a lot of good work. Ironically, according to a VFTT trail condition report the two guys that broke the trail out were "Larry and Mike" - big coincidence, as it was not us.

I have heard that this trail is harder than you would think - that is true. It is never excessively steep, but it gains 2100 feet in 2.5 miles to Crawford. Taking into account a number of flat and moderate sections it makes it pretty uphill most of the way. At times we were getting in 50-75 steps at a time and then taking a quick break. One nice diversion was the spotting of a snowshoe hare in the trail about 50 feet ahead of us. It bolted very quickly down the side hill. Very cool - a first for both of us.

Near where the Davis Path breaks out of the trees we met with two hikers who overnighted and were on the way down. We also passed by a tent that was set up in the open alpine area. Nice spot - don't think it was legal, but maybe it was on two feet of snow...

The snow was crusty in this section, as much of it had been blown away by winds since last weeks storm. The visibility came and went with the clouds. It would have been very tought ot follow the trail in this area if there were not snowshoe prints to follow.

We finally met up to the Crawford Spur we headed up the snow covered hill and were very happy to take a break at the summit. The conditions were ideal - we go to spend about 40 minutes dining and I took a bunch of nice pictures (see below), especially of the Giant Stairs, some windswept snow formations and one of the Frankenstein Trestle.

As usual, these adventures get interesting. When Larry and I hit the last section of the exposed area I had an interesting spill. My left leg went out and forward, my right leg went under me and I heard a rather unnerving "POP." I told Larry I needed a minute to assess the situation - I was really not sure how serious this might have been. It was more shocking than painful. After a few minutes I put a little weight on it and realized I could continue. The one smart decision I made (in my opinion) was to keep my boot on. The high boot with laces gave me some support and made me able to walk fairly normally.

We decided to take the tails off - I think this was key to the accident. The tails were causing the snowshoes to act as skis and on fluffy snow patches that had enough downward angle we went flying - most of the time in a contrlled fashion, but not when I fell. After further analysis I began to think today that the snowshoes should have been replaced with crampons as they would have provided surer footing on the descent. I would love to hear opinions from more experienced winter hikers on what the best traction decision would have been on descent, particularly on the steeper section. Snowshoes were fine futher down.

The ankle -
Well, I got home a couple of hours later, took off the boot and realized I had an issue. I could clearly see some localized swelling around the right side and top of my right ankle. I could bear weight without oo much trouble, but side to side motin was and is a problem. It seemed to get worse overnight. This morning I went to the ER and got an X-ray. The good news is it is a bad sprain with some ligament strains, but not tears. Hopefully the RICE process will yield improvements in the next few days. I do not expect to be out of commission for long.

PICTURES http://share.shutterfly.com/action/welcome?sid=8CauGbVozaNoQ&notag=1
 
I have been up to Crawford and over to Stairs, Resolution these past couple of trips before the big snow.
I climb Crawford from tme to time but always seem to forget from one year to the next that you break a pretty good sweat on the way up.

The 1st time on the descent the trail was so hard packed and slippery that I seemed to take forever on the way down through the steeper stuff.
The next week with a little more snow, I kept my snowshoes on for the majority of the day and made good time through the steep sections with out the worry of taking a spill.
I haven't been up since the big storm ..in the mountains I use a snowshoe with very aggresive claws so I have had good luck walking straight down most things.
A few years ago in spring I used an all metal snowshoe that had almost no traction...the 1st slick place I was "whomp" flat on by rear.
I would think your shoe did not have a enough bite" under the foot and the sides therefore acted more like a big pair of skates.

On the bright side..these days after trying lots of combos for shoeing/hiking etc..I just figure that on most every trip I will have the right gear for the right conditions for at least some part of my hike ...but that's about as close as it gets...well ...every so often it all works out perfectly, but more often or not I will take a spill in some way shape or form while shoeing...none to gracefully at that.

Good Luck !
 
Last edited:
I generally do take the tails off my MSRs for descent (to be honest I don't often use the tails at all, they make the shoes nosedive). They definitely add ski action to the shoes and I tend to forget the extra length and step on the tails when turning, resulting in oh so graceful face plant maneuvers. Without the tails on you can actually almost do some controlled skiing in the shoes. Had a blast coming down Beaver Brook in deep powder last winter that way.

Hope your popping noise doesn't manifest itself in a days later ouch or something long lasting.
Damon
 
Mike- very cool black and white shots. Sorry about the ankle- hope it heals up quick. There's rumor you did it on purpose to avoid hiking with me next week :D
 
Mike,

Great report, and the pictures were super. While not the most experienced hiker, I wonder if your snowshoe crampon wasn't getting deep enough into the snow to "bite" anything solid.

Sorry to hear about your ankle, heal up fast, before winter is over. I'll bet LarryD is happy he didn't have to carry/drag you down!
 
Mike, I wasn't just thinking about getting your beer. I was also eyeing some of your expensive hiking/camping gear :)

I'm starting to think I may be bad luck for you. Either our hikes become death marches which use up all available daylight, or you get hurt. (Who can forget the great cocoa incident of 2006?)
 
Well, there's another one I need to climb :rolleyes: Between Crawford, Chocorua, The Moats, and Kearsarge North I have my work cut out for me once I'm back out there!

Nice shots! Stairs is such a cool little place to be. You definitely have to get out there.

Rest the ankle, and start slow. No sense having it bother you all summer...
 
Glad you got that hike, Mike. It really is a jewel. Enjoyed your pictures...some great ones as usual. Sorry about your ankle. Descending on snow shoes has its tricky moments. I try not to use my tails on the MSR's and really shy away from them on descents. I like to do almost a heel plunge with the short shoe when the snow is light and deep.

Look forward to hitting the trail with you soon.
 
Sorry to hear that Mike, I hope everything heals soon.

I have hiked with a lot of people with the MSR Denali's, and I have to say I'm not impressed with them that much. They don't seem to get the traction of other snowshoes, up or down hills. I have seen the MSR Lightnings do some great stuff, but I've also seen the edge crampons worn to almost nothing as well. I love my Atlas 1025's, they have a great crampon setup, for up and down hills, and have provided me with many years of service. The binding is also great, 2 straps to pull and you're done, but they do tend to kick a lot of snow. I just picked up a set of MSR Denali's (older set) with the 4" tails for $5 at Goodwill though, couldn't pass them up for that price.

When descending really steep trails with a lot of snow on them, I usually ride back on my snowshoes and lift my toes slightly, riding out the glide in a controlled manner. If it's really steep, I'll change to my crampons, but I've even slid in them coming down some trails with deep snow, sometimes there just isn't much you can do.

I hope your ankle heals well. I had something like that happen in the Army (but I ran off a cliff at night, long story), and they misdiagnosed the fracture as a sprain. The original X-rays didn't show the hairline break well, and I wound up walking on it for a few months until it got a lot worse. I had surgery to remove the bone fragments and cartilage it messed up, but it healed well and to this day I honestly could not tell you which ankle had the problem. I'm just saying that if it seems to be taking longer than it should to heal, definitely have it checked out again.
 
Yikes! Sorry, Mike, I'm sure it will get well quickly.

I won't even consider the tails; it seems to me that adding 4" on the back, but nothing on the front, of the snowshoe will make for an imbalanced situation. It wasn't clear to me that your accident happened *because* you took the tails off, or that you *should* have taken them off?

I will take pretty steep descents with my snowshoes on as long as the snow is loose. Once it packs hard then I'll consider real crampons or even a bareboot slide if appropriate.* But if it's "skiable" then with the snowshoes still on I step the left foot forward and let it start sliding down, while my knees bend down like a tele turn and my right foot goes way back and acts like a brake/rudder. I don't actually try to parallel ski with my snowshoes.

*my MSR's are new to me this year so they haven't seen late-winter hard packed trail yet; given how much I've been impressed with the full-length crampon they have, I may adjust my habits.
 
Great trip report.

Ouch! Mike - hope you heal well and soon. Great trip report. I'll look at your photos, too.

I've had good luck on my atlas snowshoes. I will admit semi-skiing on the Crawford path on the way down recently. This made for some hilarious moments when ducking a tree and then forgetting to not cross my snowshoes, ergo immediate face plant.

I've concluded to use crampons more often on slippery downslopes, although given the conditions that day, even with snowshoes on, stepping off the trail resulted in snow up to my hips.

--Mike
 
Mike - maybe you should add a stretcher sled to your extensive gear list :rolleyes:

Glad your ankle is recovering. Hopefully you can shed that cane soon, as they are not in fashion these days.

Great TR and pix as always. See you soon!

Marty
 
Top