Donaldson and Emmons, August 15

vftt.org

Help Support vftt.org:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

teejay

New member
Joined
Sep 4, 2003
Messages
521
Reaction score
61
Location
The Beautiful Finger Lakes; Avatar: 4 Hrs. up, 4
I met up with Audrey, Pat, Marge and LittleBear at the Coreys Rd. trailhead in heavy rain for the hike in to the Calkins Brook campsite on Sunday, Aug. 14. After extensive deliberation and waiting for what seemed to be an eternity (maybe as long as 20 minutes) for the rain to pass, we reached the group decision to climb the Sewards as a day hike on Monday. The rest of Monday afternoon was spent under the tarp (cabin roof) at Northwoods Cabins near Tupper Lake. BTW, this is probably the closest motel/cabin to the trailhead, about half an hour total including the road in to the trailhead. It’s not fancy at all, a bit worn out and seedy, in fact, but we were all very comfortable there.

That evening we dined on camp food cooked over a stove on the porch of the cabin. Lentil soup, tortellini with Alfredo sauce and home-made blueberry sauce on pound cake with Cool Whip topping. We ate well.

Monday morning, after a hearty breakfast, we were off to the trailhead at an early hour. Mostly clear skies were overhead as we hit the trail at 6:16 AM and walked the easy 3.3 mile hike to the start of the herd path, which was reached at 7:28. We set a rapid clip trying to keep pace with a highly motivated Audrey.

The herd path, as has been written here many times, presented minimal challenge to follow. It is very well defined its entire length. The blowdown which is encountered is more annoying than difficult. The climb is fairly continuous with some easy scrambles. As the herd path approaches the ridge line, there are some limited views of Ampersand and Seward to the left. When the herdpath meets the Seward-Donaldson path near the ridge, there is an awesome and somewhat intimidating (we would agree later) view of Seward. This junction is very obvious with a well defined herd path leading left and down toward Seward and the trail to Donaldson up and to the right. Total time to this point was 3 hrs. 50 mins. including stops.

Just a few minutes after the junction a wonderful western view point just 50 -75 ft. to the right of the main trail is reached. A second viewpoint (“AFV”-Audrey) is reached at a high point shortly afterward (4 hrs. 5 mins.). More about this later. Continuing on we reached what appeared to be the summit but could find no sign or disk. I climbed on what seemed to be the summit rock and looked back at the previous highpoint, which appeared higher. Had we walked right past the summit?

The trail begins a slow descent with some interesting scrambles then ascends and stops on a rock at a highpoint. Emmons, there is a disk high in a tree. The summit is mostly tree covered but there are limited views to the west toward Tupper Lake and north toward Seward providing a different perspective from what we had seen earlier. We reached the summit at 11:31, 5 hrs. 15 mins. from the start.

We started back toward Donaldson determined to find the summit and regrouped at the second viewpoint mentioned above for a long lunch break. It was there that Marge noticed the summit disk high in a tree behind us. Yes, for the first time in memory, I had actually walked over a summit without realizing it. The trip between Donaldson and Emmons had taken a bit over an hour in each direction.

The view is about 180 deg. looking east. The High Peaks are spread panoramically in front of you from Seymour to Couchsacraga. Perhaps it was my low expectation initially from Burnside’s view rating (40th), but I think this is one of the more spectacular vantage points in the western High Peaks, clearly superior to Panther’s (21st), my only other western peak. We did Emmons, we savored Donaldson.

Throughout the hike the group had shifted its focus from completing the range that day to completing the hike while we still had some energy remaining for the hike down and the tedious walk out to the parking area. Seward would have to wait. We reached the cars, 3 ½ hours after leaving Donaldson’s summit, at 5:02 PM. Total time including rest/filter/regroup/summit stops, 10 hrs. 46 mins., 15+ miles.

Back to the Northwoods Cabins for a second night. See, we really liked the place.

Lessons learned: Donaldson is a destination. The herd path draws about as much blood as any other. Roots, no matter how they look or how you step on them, are slippery. And you WILL slip. Guaranteed. Roots are your friend only if can grab them.
 
Last edited:
teejay said:
Roots are your friend only if can grab them.

Know that lesson!

Nice report, sorry about the lack of Seward on the list. It isn't a tuff run over to it and back, but as you write, it is a long down and out, and out and out... Calkins Brook is wonderful to be in, however.

Your Emmons post neglected to mention views over to Long Lake - this was one of the first times I had to see it -- western ADK specialty, and you didn't mention a BSM index on the trail over. I know it had to be there!!

Great to hear that you enjoyed it. What is the plan for the rest of the group? They have a day for Seward to still make Marshall on Friday? The weather looks very good for them. Fun people to hike with!!

See ya Sat....
 
bubba,

The group plans to attack Seward from Blueberry Trail on Thursday, a free day they had planned, as a day hike. They are also planning Hough via Lillian Brook tomorrow as a day hike. On schedule for Marshall on Friday.

Long Lake? Either I missed it or mistakenly identified it as Big Tupper.

Now, for BSM. There was some mud on the trail. Most of it was supportive, i.e. mud with a bottom. You could walk pretty much right through it, BSM's 1-2. The worst stretch was between the two Donaldson summits. On the way out to Emmons it wasn't evident, but there is a well worn route around it. It's on the right going to Emmons but is much easier to spot on the way back. The bog isn't that long (40-50 ft. but was deep enough (over the boot) to receive a rating. No more than a 3 or 4. By comparison, from the start of the Santanoni herd path to Bradley Pond lean-to is about 8.5. Distance: Hundreds of feet; Depth: Bottomless. I've never seen a 9.

teejay
 
Last edited:
Great report. I love the views from Donaldson as well. My first trip over the three I walked right past the Seward sign. Didn't notice it until losing the northside path and making a hasty (and shortlived) retreat toward the CB. At that point in the hike (solo and midweek, out of water and food, drenched and not singing, etc. etc. ) I just said an understated: oh...

btw, here's what the Emmons summit looked like this past Christmas...
 
Teejay -
That view of Long Lake from Emmons is classic. Next time you take the rte. 30 bridge in Long Lake village, look NE and you'll see where you were.
 
Here's another cheer for the vista from Donaldson. My friend and I didn't get to Emmons when we came up from Blueberry a few weeks ago, and I plan to go back via this Calkins Brook route that's sweeping the nation. Sounds eminently dayhikable.

Matt
 
teejay said:
The group plans to attack Seward from Blueberry Trail on Thursday, a free day they had planned, as a day hike.

I did Seward from the North a few weeks ago (trip report here). Be prepared for lots of mud on the lower slopes.
 
Teejay, Great report. I will have to get some specific notes this weekend from you. And Bubba, I can't believe you would question Teejay about what he saw, especially after our "Wallface confusion" when we were up on Panther a few weeks ago (hahahaha)! slamdog
 
Rico - you're SICK! Take a picture of what (truly) looks like BSM=9 for sure!! And that would be where??? I want to stay away!!

slam - the Wallface drama was classic... did you hear about our trip out... that was almost as classic ...in true 'bubba' style! I'll save it for the campfire.
 
My apologies

to Tom Rankin. I just reread your "boot sucking mud" post and realized it only goes from 1 to 5. So, the BSM index for the stretch between Donaldson's summits should be about 2, but the Bradley Pond trail from the start of the Santanoni herd path to the lean-to is 4+.

teejay
 
Top