Yes Carol, I've actually emailed TJ about it.. Like mentioned here, Balsam Lake is a nice firetower and a nice hike. I can use that to count for my winter peaks.. hahahaha. Actually I think I've already done those in winter season, just I never recorded the date. No matter. The hut at the top is in very good shape. The last time I was there, a friend and I were commenting on how new the exhaust tower on top of the cabin looked.
The Catskills 3500 tally list never mentioned about getting permission, just to respect the property which I already do, whether it's private or not. I never got permission from anybody when I did graham, but now I'm curious.
Jay