You might not find this response helpful, and if so I apologize, but --
If you have any fondness for snowshoeing, I can't think of a better peak to wait until late winter for. MacNaughton is covered with shwack and blowdown, but a good supportive Feb-March snowpack does wonders to float you over the worst of it. It makes a really nice winter trip. I went last March, and I can remember thinking in one spot after another, "man, this would be a nightmare in summer." We went up the bumpy south ridge from the end of Henderson Lake, and descended to Preston Ponds. It makes a nice loop with varied scenery, of a reasonable day-trip length (10 miles or so??).
It just doesn't look like much fun wading at ground level through all the junk up there.