ADKPooh (and others),
I can't speak to kids and carriers, as I have no practical experience in it.
But I hear what you saying and agree with much of it. I just have to add a couple caveats, if I may. I (have and do) hike extensively with my children. In the past 8 years or so, All of us have spent well over 1000 hrs romping through the Adirondack woods together (on and off trail). We've completed the 46 and my son is has over 70 at the ADK HH and seems to be equally at ease on and off-trail. We've done a few things together that I certainly had to give him the "Don't tell your mom about this okay" (right Peakbagr
). He has successfully navigated up and down peaks that have NO TRAIL anywhere near then. My daughter is no slouch either. As many that have hiked with her can attest, she will outhike 80% of the adults she hikes with, She's done some stuff that almost killed us and she didn't shut up to catch her breath all day
. They are 14 and 12 respectively. My point is, by many standards, I would consider that my kids are as experienced, and in many cases MORSO, from a hiking standpoint than many that you may come across out there.
FOR THE MOST PART (**see below**) would not hesitate to let them wander a few minutes ahead of me on the trail. They have demonstrated and earned that right over the years to take those baby steps forward. Now, I really longer teach them, they learn by doing and experiencing. My point is not to brag on them (although I am proud), I just want to point out that it may be THEM (or others like them as they are NOT unique in this) that you pass by. You may see this 14 & 12 year old go by, and my wife and I following a few minutes behind, and I might certainly ask you "Hey, did you see two kids go by" (as a normal "keeping tabs" remark). I would hope that you would not think "God, what horrible parents". I'd like to think that that is not the case. Perhaps it's me that's wrong though.
Its not an altogether uncommon scenario. About a year ago, we were strolling by the JLB at about 6PM (in summer) after completing a Haystack, Basin, Saddleback loop. There was this couple that were sitting on the deck that obviously saw us go by at about 7 AM that morning. The woman looked over and LOUDLY (so as we would hear). said "I can't believe those people kept that POOR little girl out there all day". I was fumed and wanted to say something, but knew I wouldn't. My astute 11 y/o daughter however, calmly walked over and purposely took her pack off (we were taking a break) and laid it on the deck, 46r patch obviously face up, right next to her. Seems as the remark irked her as well.
So I guess the purpose is just to remind everyone that not all kids you see out there are disrespectful and totally clueless neophytes or as tender as their years may make them appear.
--------------------------------
I MUST ADD - While I am very comfortable with my kids backcountry experience and skills, I sometimes do forget that they are still kids. I must remember that and would remind those that are getting into hiking, or are still in the process of hiking with kids too. As they get more experience, we tend to forget that. For example, About a year ago, coming off Redfield, we let my son (then 13) drift about ahead of us coming down (he descends faster then we like). No biggie, he certainly was capable of following the trail down and had proved that to us over and over. We had NO ISSUE with that, and besides, he was literally only 100 yds ahead of us.
What perhaps he wasn't prepared for was coming face to face with a 300 lb Black Bear rummaging off the side of the trail. It ambled off quickly and most of us would agree, an incidental sighting of one of the most majestic of Adirondack creatures, is awe inspiring. I will tell tell you, to a 13 year old BOY alone in the woods (in his own mind anyway), it can be a terrifying experience. Later though, he thought it was cool and denied how really SCARED he was (of course
)
So we must continue to teach and allow our children to grown and ultimately form their OWN bond with the great outdoors, but we cannot unleash them to discover it too quickly either. It's a delicate balance.
Sorry this is so long, I just got to writing and it got away from me.