I hiked a short section of the CT over the weekend near Kelsey Notch and South Baldhead Mountain, and I came away with mixed feelings about the trail. In some places it was wonderful - a well-defined treadway, easy to follow blazes, natural beauty in abundance, etc.
In other places (probably more than half of the distance that I hiked) the trail was just a mess. Poor drainage, no stepping stones in place, muck, undefined treadways... it was on the verge of a bushwhack except for the bright yellow blazes. Speaking of blazes, I was surprised to see that some were carved into trees, more than a few trees had "CT" painted on them (as if you didn't know what trail you were following already), and I even saw that one person had painted "Hi" in yellow paint next to their yellow blaze. Some blazes were straight, others were squiggly lines, others were right angles to mark turns... there seemed to be no consistency to the trail markings. It just looked haphazard.
My mixed feelings were this: Part of me thought that the trail was a disaster and it is no wonder why it has been so hard to keep this project alive. It appeared to be poorly laid out and poorly maintained. There has been little interest in this trail for a reason - it just isn't that enjoyable in its current state.
Another part of me felt that this is a trail that could be something special. If enough people dedicated time and effort to develop and maintain the trail, it could really be a jewel of the north country. There are many spectacular peaks and lots of wildlife to be seen up there. The article was correct in that the CT offers far, FAR more solitude than the Whites.
In the end, I decided that at some point I will contact the organization and volunteer to do some trail work. Whether I actually do that or not is a function of my desire to see this trail succeed versus the real cost of driving 3.5 hours each way to work on a remote stretch of trail that only a tiny fraction of NH's hiking community will experience. I sincerely hope that everyone gives at least a section of the CT a try, whether they support the project or not, before they form an opinion of it. Not all trails are created equal.