Scar W (#100)

vftt.org

Help Support vftt.org:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

buckyball1

New member
Joined
May 18, 2005
Messages
426
Reaction score
62
Location
Orrington, ME
Where to start? First the "academy award" speech. Thanks to all on the Board who have helped me in the last year. Amicus with getting me started on these last 24 in August 2006 and for innumerable pieces of advice, B&G and PBear for web site info on many hikes, Nate and Neil for for repeated thoughts/ideas, Micheal J and bigmoose for advice on Scar W route, Dugan, Rocks & Rolls and SilentCal for great company and support yesterday--am sure there are more of you i missed --thanks

Somehow i managed to leave Scar to last on this list and headed over there in July to solo it from the N Loon side after getting route advice from Amicus. I misinterpreted some good advice and being already whipped from tough hiking the day before made some errors and came nowhere near what i now call the "magic line". After hours of thrashing, i ended up in a dismally thick, steep area north of the peak and retreated (in disarray as Amicus would later say :) ), glad to just get out in one piece. This was my first "fail to summit" since a wack of Sunrise in the Sentinals (ADK) in 88 or 89 and i really let it play with my mind (for a week i was going to stop the solo wacking again forever)

But you know how it goes...so back i go yesterday, this time with the company of SilentCal, Dugan and Rocks&Rolls,a great group of new friends for this usually solitary hiker. I had watched the weather since last Monday and saw Saturday as the only "bad" stretch surrounded by days of sunshine; I was sure the forecast would change/move by at least 12 hours as it "always" does , but it was spot on. I spent the night car camping in one of my $3 special NFS sites and woke around midnight to the pitter patter on the roof and then steady rain starting about 1:30. I met the gang at McDonalds in Lincoln at 6:30 and seriously considered just driving home... but off we went

I had gotten permission to park behind the main lodge at Loon (they were great to me, but be a bit careful as there are serious concerns re privacy/security here) and we headed up the left most ski slope, Walkin' Boss. It was coolish, still raining and got progressively windier as we ascended, great hypothermia conditions. A Loon employee who is also a S&R guy talked to us with a worried look in his eye as we left the bottom and mentioned "maybe some snow up high today"-yikes. The ski slope was the usual calf/achilles burner (maybe 2000 feet in 1.5 ? miles) and we huddled near the gondola at the top and geared up for the woods ahead.(by now we were all totally soaked, my leather boots were already squishy even after slathering on SnoSeal on Thursday and i'm sure people were wondering "why the hell are we up here today?"

After 2 goes, I'd opine :) that the Loon N approach to Scar W may be a "better" one if you hit what i now call the "magic line" the Amicus group followed earlier this year, but it's a very thin corrider . With more advice from Amicus, Micheal J and bigmoose, i was convinced i now had this route down pat--hah, hah, hah. I was lucky to immediately find the herdpath which goes much of the way to Black (lucky because the last time, it took me 40! minutes to find this and i was too upset coming out to notice where it really was). We followed the herdpath for about 1/2 mile and turned toward the peak just as the path swings from east and slightly ENE to almost north towards Black--the same spot i tried in July.

The terrain back in here is not at all obvious, you can't just go "up" and visuals are very limited. Trying to follow good advice, I suggested we stick to a curving course about 100' or so north of the ridgeline to a point about 0.3 miles "below" the summit and then head east.This is what i thought would take us on the line with relatively (for Scar) mild wacking conditions. The rest of the crew graciously agreed to my plan and the mistakes we made were all mine. For the first 0.1, all went well,but then we starting hitting thicker stuff and the going got slow and hard, still maybe 1/2 mile to go before the turn due east toward the summit-we talked constantly to make sure we keep track of one another in the dense cover-we were also getting a bit chilled by now and "should we go on?" was on everyone's mind --just could not find a good way up. After much effort we finally reached the point about 0.3 miles below the summit and felt it might be doable now, but damn it was getting cold and those woods were often dark, wet, tight and and miserable.------note to anyone headed up here--i think the magic line is VERY close to the north ridge perhaps even on the ridgeline coming up from the herdpath--even out 100' or so to the north might just as well beeen a mile off--and i should have "listened to the mountian" as i often do rather than slavishly stick to my directional bearing plan.

The last 1/4 mile to the summit wasn't too bad, a few thick bands at bottom and top, but pretty decent going. The top is a nice large flat open area. There is an obvious can, nicely done and well placed by bigmoose--only 2 entries since placement earlier this summer. Quick congratulations and time to head down as it's now getting chilly and we face the "crap" again going down. Since the line going up failed, we decide a straight shot course toward the herdpath jumpoff spot can't be any worse--wrong again. We end up crossing over the ridge and slip way too far down on the south side. We get one of our few visuals (of Black i think, not having my glasses on and Silentcal tells me it's the gondola on N Loon--we are way off our line)You know how this goes; when you try to sidehill to correct in thick stuff it just seems to force you further off/down. It's gets crazy thick here, we are slowed almost to a crawl and often can't see one another even 6-7 feet away- this is the time even i wonder why am i doing this stuff.

After a stretch of very tough going, we reach the herdpath near where we started.A final indignity is about 0.1 miles from the ski slope we lose the herdpath at a large blowdown patch right where i lost it in July--but we're close and soon are on the ski slopes. Spirits soar and we return to the bottom under a windy, but no-rain, slightly clearing sky.

Dugan surprises me with a few bottles of good homebrew cider/mead and cookies, we toast the top, talk about our day and each turn toward home.

Thanks again to D/R&R/SC

(oh, and now it's finish the 50F list (5 left)-Moxie next week?)

jim
 
Last edited:
Congratulations Buckyball-- I wondered if you and the group would brave the weather or postpone to another day. Congrats on finishing this list -- and in advance for finishing the next one so soon afterwards! :)

- Ivy
 
I hate to say it, but I weenied out within a few tenths of the summit. I was cold and wet and moving wasn't helping me to warm up, and also having an off day health-wise.

We agreed to split the group with SilentCal and Bucky making a push for the summit, while RnR and I turned back. Well... we got even further south into the ravine than they did. At one point we could see the green building on Loon, and the col where the herd path crosses through. We took a bearing on the col because we wanted to be sure head so far east that we'd miss the herd path. Thankfully, the close packed spruce cut the wind and the struggle helped me to warm up. Our heading took us far enough down that we crossed what looked to be the beginnings of the drainage. The areas we passed through were beautiful, but at times a struggle to get through. Even the moose aren't so stupid as to make paths here!

Before we knew it, we were headed back uphill to (hopefully) the col and herdpath. Since I was leading this portion, I was the first to see indicators that the ridge top was near. We reached it, went a little downhill, noticed that the land began descending steeply to the north, then noticed - aha, we're on the herd path! We were pretty sure we'd reasoned well and stuck to a bearing, but it was a relief to pop out not only on the path, but just about exactly where we'd headed for. Guess that day of map & compass class was worth something after all!

We debated whether Cal and Bucky were ahead or behind, and what they might do if they were to reach the car and not find us there. We agreed that it would be a mighty huge coincidence if we all reached the same portion of the path at the same time. We walked along for about 5 minutes talking about this when from behind we heard, "hellooooo". Talk about coincidences!

We finished the rest of the hike with little difficulty. The sunlight that hit the ski slope for our descent was a quite welcome change from the rain and wind of our ascent. Cal graciously agreed to host us all in his little vacation cabin so we could dry off, change into dry clothes, and warm up.

Once settled, I surprised Bucky with some homebrewed vanilla mead, wine cider, and currant cider. As the recipient, he decreed that we would split these amongst us, sharing as well some fruitcake cookies. We toasted Bucky's accomplishment, delivered him back to his car, then went on home, with a stop at the Mountain Wanderer along the way.
 
Congratulations, Buckyball! I think your experience shows that even with input from others, bushwhacks like this one are still individual adventures. Sorry the whole group didn't make it, but it just means when you go back that you'll know exactly what to do. :)
 
I love how whackers try to give directions through a square mile of dense featureless balsams! We did that route some years ago and got pretty lucky- the balsams were fairly young and not underlaid with blowdowns, so we were mostly "swimming" up- and downhill. Congrats!
 
Way to go, jim! I knew you wouldn't be balked twice by any mountain. Kinda poetic or somethin' that we should finish our NEHH on the same day (but in different States).

'Better lucky than good' is definitely the 'whackers motto. We had less data to go by for July 7 hike, but hit that "margic carpet" to the top, which may well be nearly on the ridge-line (not a sharp one), as you surmise.

You had a great Kroo! (So did I.) Dugan - many top-notch hikers have needed two cracks at Scar Ridge W. - ask jim!
 
It was a pleasure to accompany you on this trip. Thanks for putting up with this bushwhacking novice. I had to laugh at some of the crazy thick stuff we were pushing through. I'll admit there were times I thought to myself "this is nuts!". All in all, it was a great experience and one I won't forget for awhile.

BTW. I spotted a deer on the descent of the Walkin' Boss. He sprinted about 75 yards downhill before retreating into the woods.
 
Great report!
Someone should compile all the various Scar reports and put 'em in book form. A book of horrors. (Not for the faint of heart.)
Scar whacks are tough enough without componding the woes with weather.
Congratulations, you two, for sticking with it through very trying conditions.
And kudos to Buckyball 1 on finishing the NEHH in grand style.
 
Congrats on finishing the list, Jim. I would have liked to join you.

Good luck on Moxie next weekend. I hope the sun is shining on you as you complete the "Papa Bear Double" - Hundred Highest and Fifty Finest! That is exclusive company to be in!
 
It was a true pleasure to hike with you Buckyball! It would have been even better to make it to the summit with you and SC, but I'm sure I'll long remember the adventure Dugan and I had on our way out. I guess that's what I get for saying Scar shouldn't be too easy :rolleyes:

I guess I'll have to give it another try next year. Maybe try for the whole ridge :eek: ?
 
even yesterday, i would have said i'd never consider going back with you for the ridge, but today and if the weather were good, who knows :) --thanks---jim
 
Hell, I'll go back with ya! It wasn't a horror story ... I found it fun!
:)
 
SteveHiker said:
just bring a GPS that knows north from south next time.

As I recall, it was the compass-bearers who started in the wrong direction and the developing GPS track that corrected us :D

(regardless of the fact the GPS had, indeed, flipped its compass for some reason)
 
Just wait for a dry and sunny day next time! Trust me, it will change the mood completely. :)
 
Top