Officially, this trail is still closed by the DEC. Hikers are still allowed to attempt to hike it, but they should do so knowing that there is no guarantee that the trail is passable.
I say attempt, because a friend of mine tried to hike this trail this fall, and said that the trail "simply doesn't exist anymore." Apparently, large sections of this trail were washed away by the hurricane. About halfway back to the garden, they gave up, crossed Johns Brook where they were, bushwhacked up to the main trail on the north side, and took that back to the trail head.
I'm sure that this trail will be repaired at some point- it was actually an ATV trail that was used by the ADK, as well as camp owners to access their private in-holdings in the Johns Brook Valley.