Well, Mike . . . first, let me thank you for the broken path from Spaulding to Sugarloaf, as it allowed us to hike a bit faster since we didn't have to spend as much time trail finding.
We hike up the maintenance "trail" thinking it would help us not be noticed as much, we were wrong. I do think our overnight packs combined with the fact that when asked I told her our plans probably bit us in the butt. However, even when I asked if we could just hike to the top of the mountain so we could atleast get Sugarloaf or asking if there was a closed trail we could take got us no cooperation. She did say we couldn't hike out of bounds from their property just like you heard also. She gave us a lot of rules, all of which we were apparently breaking.
What actually really shocked me and what I think was the most concerning about the entire encounter was when she tried to "be helpful". I was begging her to understand that we had just driven through the night for 9 hours and to PLEASE let us hike on the side up any trail of her choice, she made a few suggestions, all of which bordered on ridiculous and even dangerous if someone who wasn't as well acquainted with the area took her advice.
First she suggested that we hike up Burnt Mountain which would allow us to access the AT, um NO . . . I have hiked the AT and that is not true. I said, please show me on my map where this Burnt Mountain - AT intersection happens, she didn't want to show me. Then she proceeded to suggest that we access the AT from Route 27 and climb Sugarloaf from Route 27 . . . I must have looked as shocked as I felt . . . I said to her that going up and over the Crockers, crossing a huge raging river and climbing up Sugarloaf up that scary steep section from the North was not my idea of a doable trip in Winter for my level of comfort.
I know she was just trying to "help" but it is a good thing we knew the area and didn't blindly follow her advice. A novice or someone who just blindly followed her suggestions could have easily gotten themselves in trouble. It would probably not be an acceptable liability risk if someone got themselves hurt based on her advice.
But, for what it is worth, I think we enjoyed our route from Caribou Pond MUCH MUCH more than the ski trails anyway, so maybe we have Sugarloaf to Thank for our wonderful bushwhacking adventure . . .
Thanks again for the broken trail.
sli74