I made it to the top of the Captain quite a while ago. Took first logging road on right after Sawyer Pond parking lot, and went into the valley. Followed the stream up between Captain and Hancock, where there is a nice ribbon of open granite to walk on. Then scratched up to the right to the top. Visited Carrigain Pond on way down.
On my second attempt, done at the time that Sawyer Pond Road was closed for repairs from a landslide, I was hiking up that granite ribbon between Hancock and the Captain. I climbed up a short steep secion of rock, felt a scrape on my left leg, looked down and had a 3 inch gash in my leg.
Tied my t-shirt around it and walked out. Dunked it a few times in brook water. Felt like I was returning from Getteysburg out on the Sawyer Pond road, with bikers going by.
Got 20 stiches. The nurse was upset to see hemlock needles in the cut, but it was probably a hell of a lot cleaner than most cuts.