I've become less and less driven by lists since I got down to two hikes (Owl's Head and a three day backpack) left on my NH48. With that said, I have been repeating lots of peaks, and haven't bothered to care when I did them. I do write down VT peaks when I do them, and will likely do the same when I get a few ME ones in. This is the difference between agressive peak bagging and keeping track. I don't get why you wouldn't keep any record, but I don't think the list needs to dictate decisions either. Of course I don't write down the peaks on those other lists I will never finish. I have done a handful of HH peaks - but due to several of these being bushwhacks (NO interest AT ALL) - I will never complete it.
I should probably write down my winter peaks, especially since it is a specific recognition and everything. Though who knows if I will even bother to send my stuff in/attend the banquet, etc.
Spring vs. fall vs. summer, etc, with exact hikes in mind - to me its kind of splitting hairs. I will often be drawn to broad areas do to seasons (or more importantly conditions - they mean more to me than dates). I hadn't done anything in the Willey Range at a snowy time, so I recently did. I haven't done any hiking in Waterville Valley in foliage season, so this fall I'm sure I will.
Visiting all the different areas of the Whites in different times of year is something I like to do. Worrying about exact date ranges, and being concerned that I have done Kinsman but not Moosilauke, or Madison but not Adams at a particular time - thats not a big deal to me. Hiking with too many rigid rules and goals in mind makes it less appealing.
Hiking is the least formal thing I do. My job, coaching and referee commitments, volunteer work, etc. are all full of schedules, deadlines, tangible goals and stuff like that. Hiking lacks these things (to me), its one of the few low key, spontaneous, just for fun things I have left. Being a slave to eight different lists in seasons, days, time of day (whos going to be the first to summit every peak at 1:37 pm) just makes it a third job. Although I enjoy my other two, they have their stressful moments.
As far as less traffic, this time of year sees hiking become less complicated. Conditions/gear requirements are steadily getting more predictable. Probably why there is less Q&A. It seems to me that more people hike more often as winter goes away - its just that there is less concern out there regarding the hikes.
The lack of public registration also has cut down on traffic to this site. There are people who lose interest, but less new people to come into the fold and be gung ho - as many people who get newly involved in anything often are. The defection over to other sites also has cut down on traffic.
With that said, I do understand why the change was made. While there has been less overall traffic, there is a lot less negative traffic, which is good. Some of the bad eggs were active eggs.