Second (third? fourth? fifth?) for Woodstock Inn / Woodstock Station... good food, reasonable prices, and excellent beer (my personal favorite is the Pig's Ear Brown). I haven't tried the finer dining in the Clement Room, however.
Speaking of Pig's Ears -- it seems to be a hit-or-miss proposition as I am not actually sure when they're open, but when we've managed to hit it, the take-out BBQ from Pig's Ear / Texas Toast Eatery was pretty tasty.
And further on the subject of barbeque -- I haven't been in George's Seafood Too in Lincoln, but the first outlet on the Tenney Mountain Highway in Plymouth is pretty good and very reasonable, especially if you hit them on a "special night" for ribs.