I dayhiked the Santas two weeks ago with my son. Took about 13 3/4 hours in close to perfect conditions. We spent about 1/2 hour on each summit.
The trail to Bradley Pond is very mucky, especially towards the herd path turn-off. If you look at Joel's Adirondack Journey site, you will have no problem at all finding the herd path start, as has been noted.
When you make the turn onto the herd path, you will cross an open area and then enter the woods. Because a number of preople have apparently camped there, it is tromped out pretty good, which leaves the herd path almost indiscernible for about fifty yards, There is one that goes left and one that goes right, both will meet within a few minutes under some cliffs. Bradley Pond will be visable through the woods.
When the path reaches Panther Brook, you will cross it and follow a very nice herd path up the left side. As the brook begins to narrow out, you will cross back over. The cairns are very easy to follow. From there it goes up steeply, in and out of the fading brook. Make sure you have full water before leaving this brook entirely. There are no potable water sources from this point on.
You will come to a three-way (a "T", if you will) intersection. This area is not as open as you might think. Keeps a heads up because the old herd path is still discernible straight ahead and you might pass over this intersection. It won't matter, because I believe it will take you to Times Square, anyway. I did not notice the carved tree, but someone had scratched an "S" and an arrow on a rock which will direct you to Times Square.The trail to the right will take you to Panther within ten to 15 minutes. We did this first to get the psychological boost of a peak. Plus, it was nice to have in our pockets when it was time to head back. You descend for a bit then make a final summit climb to the summit ledge. The marker is in the woods a bit. Nice views of the Sewards, Santa, and Couch.
The trip back to Times Square will take about 15 minutes. T/S is unique. There is no mistaking it. It was smaller than I had imagined it, but it looks just like the pictures. The herd paths at the far end (Couch right and Santa left) are very easy to follow.
Couch is a longer hike than it should be. Dan and I took exactly 1 1/2 hours each way, moving at a steady pace. The climb down from T/S is about 2/3 of it. The herd path around the cliff, is pretty distinct and I followed that almost automatically. When crossing the swamp, try to stay a bit to the right if you can. The herd path re-entry is at about 2 o'clock from where you first enter the swamp (or about 12:00 from the cliff). When you get to the opposite end of the swamp (it was full of water when we were there, hiking poles are good route finders here), skim the edge until you see the herd path. Couch has a moving summit, it will play keep away until it is good and ready to have you find it
The path literally ends at the summit. The sign was there but on the ground when we were there. I nestled it back up in some dead spruce.
The trail to Santa is very pleasant, if mucky in some places. The views are, by far, the best of the three. The sign was up, and there are bolt holes in the summit rock.
I don't regret dayhiking this range, even though many advised backpacking to Bradley Pond (or higher). Negotiating the mud and muck with a full pack, and overnighting in what essentially is a bog negates the time saved, I think. Plus you have to "overrun" the herd path for a 1/4 mile of slogging to get to the BP lean-to. It was less than two hours in and less than two hours out from Bradley Pond. I wouldn't want to day-hike the entire range again, but I enjoyed the area. I probably will re-vist Santa and Panther again. Couch? Maybe not, but with the hindsight of two weeks, I'm thinking about it
These mountains were number 43, 44 and 45 for me. I finished on Big Slide the next day, so I had a little left in the tank afterwards.