The Presi Traverse March 21-22, a success, but not without incident

vftt.org

Help Support vftt.org:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

dangergirl

Active member
Joined
Jan 19, 2009
Messages
195
Reaction score
84
Location
homeless and couch surfing for a bit
Well, after completing the winter pemi loop last weekend, we were off to tackle the Presi Traverse. Don, Mike,Sue, and I started out Saturday morning by getting a great breakfast at the Water Wheel Restaurant. We all gave it a thumbs up! After filling our bellies I pounded a Red Bull and we headed off to Appalachia. The four of us put on our backpacks at 8:00am. Both Don and I carried 42 lbs including water. It was a beautiful day! Stunning views, blue skies, and endless sun made for a very awesome but uneventful day. We decided to bypass the summits (due to huge blisters on Sues feet)
For some reason we did summit Madison and when we got to the top we could not figure out whose idea it was. Oh, well, it was very scenic.
Conditions were very icy with some windswept snow patches. Parts of it were crusty while others were powdery. It was cool and crisp but there was almost no wind! We got to Sphinx Col at 3:30 to find that the usual camping area was a frozen pond. We dug out two tent platforms on the side of the hill and set up our tents. Later that night the wind decided to pick up. It was so loud that earplugs were useless! Due to the awkward tent sites on the side of the slope, guying out the tent was a challenge which led to a lot of flapping throughout the night. We did manage to get a lot of broken sleep and felt well rested in the morning.
We woke to very cold, windy, snowy conditions. We were in the clouds and had less than 1/10th of a mile of visibility. We were in for a treat.
We packed up camp and headed out into the wind. We did a fine job navigating and got ourselves over to the Westside trail. Don and I stopped for a quick break and Mike came up behind us. He asked where Sue was and we told him we hadn't seen her. He then told us that she was in front of him. Mike took off to go find Sue and Don and I followed. As we turned the corner Don and I saw Mike fall and start sliding down the icy slope. It didn't register what was happening until we saw Sue down the hill yelling for help. Don carefully made his way down to where Mike was able to luckily able to self arrest (with his hiking poles). I carefully made my way to Sue to find out that she had fallen in front of Mike and due to poor visibility he didn't even see it! She had hit rocks on her fall and ripped her pants, lost a pole, and cut her knee up pretty good. Mike was okay and actually stopped right where Sues pole was. We all got back up to the trail and assessed the situation and decided to carry on. We were below Mt Washington on the Westside trail when the accident happened. It scared the crap out of all of us.
When we got to Lake of the Clouds hut we realized what had happened. Mike and Sue brought Katoohla Spikes instead of Crampons. (Don and I almost did the same thing but I decided crampons were safer and worth the extra weight.) The spikes did not work well on these condtions.
When we left the hut we were welcomed with high winds and ice chards blasting us in the eyes, face, etc. Goggles were useless due to fogging and sunglasses didn't help much either. We navigated with the GPS and did a fine job staying on the trail. When we got to Eisenhower we experienced winds so strong we were almost pushed over! The wind actually hurt! We could not see Crawford Path but decided we would use the GPS to navigate because going over the summit would be too dangerous with the winds. Crawford Path was on the Leeward side of the mountain and was very calm. It was nice to have a break. When we came back around to the ridgeline we were attacked by the wind again and just wanted the trip to be over with. After what seemed like eternity we finally made it to below treeline and hiked out to the car. Sue was such a trooper! When we finished her knee looked like a purple grapefruit. We celebrated with some hot chocolate and dinner at the Moat. The clouds then lifted off the range and we had a spectacular view of the snow blowing off the ridgeline. We were so happy that we all made it. Watching your friends sliding down a slope in a white-out is a horrific experience and I never want to see that again. We learned a valuable lesson about bringing the right gear. Sometimes an extra couple of pounds can save your life.
Links to the pics are here:http://www.flickr.com/photos/kfolcik/sets/72157615803512264/
 
Wow...sounds like quite a trip! Glad the knee injury wasn't too bad and the self-arrest worked. (Seems like there was a thread round here about that very topic not too long ago.)

You guys are stylin' in those nose guards, yo... ;)
 
Great TR...it is important to always remember what it can be like up there. How quick things can turn. We all forget...especially after so many really beautiful hikes over the last few weeks.

Glad all are ok.
 
What a difference a day (or two) makes.
 
Dangergirl, great TR. Thank you for including what went wrong, as well as what went right -- that info benefits us all.

Glad you and your companions were able to make it, and that you all had the skills to safely finish what you started.
 
Thanks! I am glad we did it, but it was definately not one of my favorite trips due to the accident. I just hope that others can learn from the mistake. Light packs are nice, but safety needs to come first. Everyone gives me a hard time about bringing too much stuff and being too uptight about sketchy parts of the trip and this just confirmed that I am not in the wrong for being overly cautious. You have to plan for the worst case scenario and be prepared for it.
 
I just hope that others can learn from the mistake. Light packs are nice, but safety needs to come first. Everyone gives me a hard time about bringing too much stuff and being too uptight about sketchy parts of the trip and this just confirmed that I am not in the wrong for being overly cautious. You have to plan for the worst case scenario and be prepared for it.
I tend to carry too much junk too. However, it became very useful (potentially lifesaving) when I broke my leg BC skiing...

Doug
 
Agreed -- I admire your skills, judgment, and stamina.

Also, forgot to add in my previous post, I really like the video at the end of your picture collection. Gives a great impression of how strongly the winds were whipping about.
 
My hubby is always overpacked...not wanting to forget something necessary should something go wrong.

He is also the "cautious" one...thank GAWD as it has kept us out of trouble several times. Usually if we take something a little sketchy...it was my idea :(
 
Wow, that was certainly an eye-opening report. I'm glad everyone made it out OK. Good to hear reports like this to keep a focus on how close the good and the bad can be!
 
Glad everyone is safe too! Thanks for the pics & vids they are well-taken, providing a great account with your report. Nice job!
 
Mike and Sue brought Katoohla Spikes instead of Crampons. (Don and I almost did the same thing but I decided crampons were safer and worth the extra weight.) The spikes did not work well on these condtions.


This is a good example of the biggest issue with alternative traction devices - when to use them and when to switch to crampons. Of course, if you didn't bring crampons at all, that simplifies things ;)

With that and the weather, I think this would qualify for "epic" status.
 
Last edited:
It's amazing the contrast between your photos - the beautiful bluebird day and then the dark, stormy one that followed!

hikingmaineac and I were glad we overpacked when we did a northern traverse back in February - we were able to get from Madison to Washington on spikes, but hit a sidehill on the Crawford Path soon thereafter. Foreseeing a possible slide like the one you described in Microspikes, we switched to crampons and were thankful for the added traction.
 
After talking it over it seems like the issue with the spikes was due to the ice on the side hills and the areas where there was snow on top of ice. Instead of biting in they slid. That was all they brought with them so it was far better than nothing. The day before they worked great (In fact I was wishing I brought mine), but the snow was softer from having the sun shining on it. Crampons just have more bite in those varrying conditions.
 
Mark Twain had something to say about this.

Mark Twain had something to say about this. The man who grabs the tiger by the tail learns 50 times more about tigers than the man who simply reads about them in books. Glad you all made it out ok (if somewhat bruised). Next time you'll know far better what to carry and where to cut corners to save weight. Humm .... Will there be a next time? I've done some things that I'm glad I did, but would just as soon not do it again.
 
After talking it over it seems like the issue with the spikes was due to the ice on the side hills and the areas where there was snow on top of ice. Instead of biting in they slid. That was all they brought with them so it was far better than nothing. The day before they worked great (In fact I was wishing I brought mine), but the snow was softer from having the sun shining on it. Crampons just have more bite in those varrying conditions.


It seems like a lot was learned on this trip. I admire your tenacity. So glad that the injury/incident wasn't too serious.

I do not own microspikes, however I see people using with them all the time. They look like they have a high potential for breakage, inadequate grip on ice, and no front points. I always use full 12 point crampons (with the front points) as conditions warrant, and I find I rely on the front points a lot on steep terrain.

For the life of me, I can't understand why someone would carry both microspikes and crampons, but to each his own:confused:. Like Tim said, if you only had microspikes, your decision regarding what to use was made for you. Just curious- do you think microspikes can get a hiker (especially an inexperienced hiker) into terrain that they will not be able to negotiate?

Beautiful pics and movies, by the way.
 
Last edited:
I find Microspikes to be very useful in frozen granular conditions, as well as low angle black ice, etc.

Just curious- do you think microspikes can get a hiker (especially an inexperienced hiker) into terrain that they will not be able to negotiate?

Absolutely. I've found that they ascend much better than descend. When those things lose their grip, you may be in for a slide!
 
Top